I find a lot of poetry frankly boring.
I'm sure a lot of people find my poetry boring.
Am I a good poet? I like to think so. Others no doubt disagree.
The poetry I find boring tends to be, but is not exclusively confined to, mainstream in its general direction.
People who just write about their fairly uninteresting lives in fairly plain language are probably not going to the top of my must read list. Then again, I know several people who write like that who's work I actually do like.
Something other than the meaning of the words, or the story, has to catch my mind for me to be interested further than one reading.
Sometimes I can't get to the end of a poem because I already know where it's going. Sometimes I read a poem backward to see if it's more interesting that way around. It sometimes is...
A poem 'should surprise with a fine excess' as Keats wrote.
A lot of poetry does what a lot of poetry does. A little of the poetry I read does something I didn't know it was going to.
Most poetry is not rubbish. It's crafted well enough.
Craft is a meaningless concept when it comes to art.
What strikes me about great poetry is not how well it is written (anyone can follow all the rules and write a sonnet) but how the language catches onto the brain and won't let go.
Craft doesn't cover up a lack of ideas.